Power and Politics in the World-System

A Cross-National Analysis of Environmental Governance

  • Jamie M. Sommer University of South Florida
  • Andrew Hargrove Stony Brook University
Keywords: CO2 emissions, Anthropocene, governance, world-systems, cross-national, climate change

Abstract

While various researchers and practitioners agree that it will be hard to restructure our current global and local systems to adapt to and mitigate climate change, there is unsurprisingly great disagreement in how and if this can be accomplished and on what level(s), or if this is even what needs to be accomplished. These conversations have continued with the introduction of the “Anthropocene.” The dominant interpretation of the concept poses several solutions, one being national government restructuring to support environmental efforts and encouraging behavioral change. To join conversations that critically evaluate the conceptualization and implications of the Anthropocene with the world-systems perspective, we consider how the effectiveness of national environmental governance in reducing CO2 emissions varies by a country’s position in the global hierarchy. Using two-way fixed effects regression, this article tests how one aspect of this environmental governance, environmentally related taxes as a percentage of total tax revenue impacts CO2 emissions for 75 countries from 2000 to 2011. Given inequities in the global division of labor, which reinforce the dominance of higher-income countries and the exploitation of lower-income countries, we expect the effectiveness of environmental governance to vary tremendously by global position. Our results support the idea that the impact of environmental governance on CO2 emissions varies across countries at different income levels in the world-system, and this is due to external constraints. Such external influence is unsurprisingly neglected in dominant interpretations of the Anthropocene. In line with previous critical research, we argue that these external constraints undermine climate change solutions because they fail to address mutually reinforcing global, political, economic, and environmental inequalities.

References

Alderson, Arthur S., and François Nielsen. 2002. “Globalization and the Great U-Turn: Income Inequality Trends in 16 OECD Countries.” American Journal of Sociology 107(5): 1244-1299.

Altvater, Elmar. 2016. “The Capitalocene, or, Geoengineering Against Capitalism’s Planetary Boundaries”. Pp. 138-152 in Anthropocene or Capitalocene? Nature, History, and the Crisis of Capitalism edited by Jason W. Moore. Oakland, CA: Kairos Press.

Bartley, Tim, and Albert Bergesen. 1997. “World-System Studies of the Environment.” Journal of World-Systems Research 3: 369-380.

Boli, John, and George M. Thomas eds. 1999. Constructing World Culture: International Non-governmental Organizations Since 1875. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

Bonneuil, Christophe. 2015 “The Geological Turn: Narratives of the Anthropocene.” Pp. 17-31 in The Anthropocene and the Global Environmental Crisis: Rethinking Modernity in a New Epoch, edited by Clive Hamilton, François Gemenne, and Christophe Bonneuil. London, UK: Routledge.

Bornschier, Volker, and Christopher Chase-Dunn. 1985. Transnational Corporations and Underdevelopment. New York, NY: Praeger Publishers.

Boyd, David R. 2012. The Environmental Rights Revolution: A Global Study of Constitutions, Human Rights, and the Environment. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press.

Bradford, John Hamilton, and Alexander M. Stoner. 2017. “The Treadmill of Destruction in Comparative Perspective: A Panel Study of Military Spending and Carbon Emissions, 1960-2014.” Journal of World-Systems Research 23(2): 298-325.

Brunsson, N. 1989. The Organization of Hypocrisy: Talk, Decisions and Actions in Organizations. Copenhagen, DK: Copenhagen Business School Press.

Bryant, Raymond L., and Sinead Bailey. 1997. Third World Political Ecology. London, UK: Routledge.

Bunker, Stephen G. 1985. Underdeveloping the Amazon: Extraction, Unequal Exchange, and the Failure of the Modern State. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

Burns, Thomas J., Byron Davis, and Edward L. Kick. 1997. “Position in the World-System and National Emissions of Greenhouse Gases.” Journal of World-Systems Research 3(3): 432-466.

Chase-Dunn, Christopher. 1999. “Globalization: A World-Systems Perspective.” Journal of World-Systems Research 5(2): 187-215.

Ciplet, David, and J. Timmons Roberts. 2017. “Splintering South: Ecologically Unequal Exchange Theory in a Fragmented Global Climate.” Journal of World-Systems Research 23(2): 373-398

Clark, Brett, Andrew K. Jorgenson, and Jeffrey Kentor. 2010. “Militarization and Energy Consumption: A Test of Treadmill of Destruction Theory in Comparative Perspective.” International Journal of Sociology 40(2): 23-43.

Crenshaw, Edward M., and J. Craig Jenkins. 1996. “Social Structure and Global Climate Change: Sociological Propositions Concerning the Greenhouse Effect.” Sociological Focus 29(4): 341-358.

Conty, Arianne. 2016. “Who is to Interpret the Anthropocene? Nature and Culture in the Academy.” American University of Sharjah: University Library.

Dietz, Thomas, and Eugene A. Rosa. 1997. “Effects of Population and Affluence on CO2 Emissions.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 94(1): 175-179.

Duit, Andreas. 2016. “The Four Faces of the Environmental State: Environmental Governance Regimes in 28 Countries.” Environmental Politics 25(1): 69-91.

Ergas, Christina, and Richard York. 2012. “Women’s Status and Carbon Dioxide Emissions: A Quantitative Cross-National Analysis.” Social Science Research 41(4): 965-976.

Evans, Peter. 1979. Dependent Development: The Alliance of Multinational. London, UK: Routledge.

Evans, Peter. 1995. Embedded Autonomy: States and Industrial Transformation. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Evans, Peter, Dietrich Rueschemeyer, and Theda Skocpol, eds. 1985. Bringing the State Back In. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.

Foster, John Bellamy, Brett Clark, and Richard York. 2011. The Ecological Rift: Capitalism’s War on the Earth. New York, NY: NYU Press.

Frank, David John, Ann Hironaka, and Evan Schofer. 2000. “The Nation-State and the Natural Environment Over the Twentieth Century.” American Sociological Review 65(1): 96-116.

Frees, Edward W. 2004. Longitudinal and Panel Data: Analysis and Applications in the Social Sciences. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.

Gallagher, Kevin P., and Strom C. Thacker. 2008. “Democracy, Income, and Environmental Quality.” PERI Working Papers 124.

Gani, Azmat. 2012. “The Relationship Between Good Governance and Carbon Dioxide Emissions: Evidence from Developing Economies.” Journal of Economic Development 37(1): 77-93.

Gareau, Brian J. 2012. “Theorizing Environmental Governance of the World-System: Global Political Economy Theory and Some Applications to Stratospheric Ozone Politics.” Journal of World-Systems Research 18(2): 187-210.

Gereffi, Gary. 1989. “Rethinking Development Theory: Insights from East Asia and Latin America.” Sociological Forum 4(4): 505-533.

Grimes, Peter, and Jeffrey Kentor. 2003. “Exporting the Greenhouse: Foreign Capital Penetration and CO2 Emissions 1980-1996.” Journal of World-Systems Research 9(2): 261-275.

Halaby, Charles N. 2004. “Panel Models in Sociological Research: Theory into Practice.” Annual Review of Sociology 30: 507-544.

Haraway, Donna J. 2016. Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Cthulucene. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

Hargrove, Andrew, Mais Qandeel, and Jamie M. Sommer. 2019. “Global Governance for Climate Justice: A Cross-National Analysis of CO2 Emissions.” Global Transitions 1: 190-199.

Hornborg, Alf. 2003. “The Unequal Exchange of Time and Space: Toward a Non-Normative Ecological Theory of Exploitation.” Journal of Ecological Anthropology 7(1): 4-10.

______. 2009. “Zero-Sum World: Challenges in Conceptualizing Environmental Load Displacement and Ecologically Unequal Exchange in the World-System.” International Journal of Comparative Sociology 50(3-4): 237-262.

Hornborg, Alf, J.R. McNeill, and Joan Martinez-Alier. 2007. Rethinking Environmental History: World-System History and Global Environmental Change. Lanham, MD: AltaMira Press.

Hsiao, Cheng. 2003. Analysis of Panel Data, Second Edition. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.

Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. 2018. “Global Warming of 1.5 ºC.” Geneva, CH: IPCC: United Nations Environmental Program.

Jorgenson, Andrew K. 2003. “Consumption and Environmental Degradation: A Cross-National Analysis of the Ecological Footprint.” Social Problems 50(3): 374-394.

Jorgenson, Andrew K. 2007. “Does Foreign Investment Harm the Air We Breathe and the Water We Drink? A Cross-National Study of Carbon Dioxide Emissions and Organic Water Pollution in Less-Developed Countries, 1975 to 2000.” Organization & Environment 20(2): 137-156.

Jorgenson, Andrew K. 2009. “The Transnational Organization of Production, The Scale of Degradation, and Ecoefficiency: A Study of Carbon Dioxide Emissions in Less-Developed Countries.” Human Ecology Review 16(1): 64-74.

______. 2012. “The Sociology of Ecologically Unequal Exchange and Carbon Dioxide Emissions, 1960–2005.” Social Science Research 41(2): 242-252.

______. 2016. “Environment, Development, and Ecologically Unequal Exchange.” Sustainability 8(3): 227.

Jorgenson, Andrew K., and Thomas J. Burns. 2007. “The Political-Economic Causes of Change in the Ecological Footprints of Nations, 1991–2001: A Quantitative Investigation.” Social Science Research 36(2): 834-853.

Jorgenson, Andrew K., and Brett Clark. 2012. “Are the Economy and the Environment Decoupling? A Comparative International Study, 1960–2005.” American Journal of Sociology 118(1): 1-44.

______. 2013. “The Relationship Between National-Level Carbon Dioxide Emissions and Population Size: An Assessment of Regional and Temporal Variation, 1960–2005.” PloS one 8(2): e57107.

Jorgenson, Andrew K., Brett Clark, and Jeffrey Kentor. 2010. “Militarization and the Environment: A Panel Study of Carbon Dioxide Emissions and the Ecological Footprints of Nations, 1970–2000.” Global Environmental Politics 10(1): 7-29.

Jorgenson, Andrew K., and Christopher Dick. 2010. “Foreign Direct Investment, Environmental INGO Presence and Carbon Dioxide Emissions in Less-Developed Countries, 1980–2000.” Revista Internacional de Organizaciones 4: 129-146.

Jorgenson, Andrew K., Christopher Dick, and John M. Shandra. 2011. “World Economy, World Society, and Environmental Harms in Less‐Developed Countries.” Sociological Inquiry 81(1): 53-87.

Jorgenson, Andrew K., and James Rice. 2005. “Structural Dynamics of International Trade and Material Consumption: A Cross-National Study of the Ecological Footprints of Less-Developed Countries.” Journal of World-Systems Research 11(1): 57-77.

Kentor, Jeffrey. 2015. “Quantifying Hegemony in the World Economy.” Pp. 80-93 in Globalization, Hegemony & Power: Antisystemic Movements and the Global System, edited by Thomas Reifer. London, UK: Routledge.

Kick, Edward, Thomas Burns, Byron Davis, David Murray, and Dixie Murray. 1996. “Impacts of Domestic Population Dynamics and Foreign Wood Trade on Deforestation.” Journal of Developing Societies 12: 68-87

Lewis, Bridget. 2018. “The Role of Environmental Human Rights in Addressing Climate Change.” Pp. 151-170 in Environmental Human Rights and Climate Change edited by Bridget Lewis. Singapore: Springer.

Li, Quan, and Rafael Reuveny. 2006. “Democracy and Environmental Degradation.” International Studies Quarterly 50(4): 935-956.

Longhofer, Wesley, and Andrew Jorgenson. 2017. “Decoupling Reconsidered: Does World Society Integration Influence the Relationship Between the Environment and Economic Development?.” Social Science Research 65: 17-29.

Malm, Andreas. 2015. Fossil Capital: The Rise of Steam Power and the Roots of Global Warming. London, UK: Verso Books.

Mayer, Adam. 2017. “Will Democratization Save The Climate? An Entropy-Balanced, Random Slope Study.” International Journal of Sociology 47(2): 81-98.

McBrian, Justin. 2016. “Accumulating Extinction: Planetary Catastrophism in the Necrocene.” Pp. 116-137 in Anthropocene or Capitalocene? Nature, History, and the Crisis of Capitalism, edited by Jason W. Moore. Oakland, CA: Kairos Press.

Melo-Escrihuela, Carme. 2008. “Promoting Ecological Citizenship: Rights, Duties and Political Agency.” ACME: An International E-Journal for Critical Geographies 7(2): 113-134.

Moore, Jason W. 2014. “The Capitalocene, Part I: On the Nature and Origins of our Ecological Crisis.” The Journal of Peasant Studies 44(3): 594-630.

______, ed. 2016. Anthropocene or Capitalocene? Nature, History and the Crisis of Capitalism. Oakland, CA: Kairos Press.

Neumayer, Eric. 2002. “Do Democracies Exhibit Stronger International Environmental Commitment? A Cross-Country Analysis.” Journal of Peace Research 39(2): 139-164.

Page, Edward A., and Michael Redclift, eds. 2002. Human Security and the Environment: International Comparisons. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.

Roberts, J. Timmons, and Peter E. Grimes. 1997. “Carbon Intensity and Economic Development 1962-91: A Brief Exploration of the Environmental Kuznets Curve.” World Development 25(2): 191-198.

______. 2003. “Social Roots of Global Environmental Change: A World-Systems Analysis of Carbon Dioxide Emissions.” Journal of World-Systems Research 9(2): 277-315.

Gould, Kenneth A., David N. Pellow, and Allan Schnaiberg. 2008. The Treadmill of Production: Injustice and Unsustainability in the Global Economy. Boulder, CO: Paradigm.

Scruggs, Lyle A. 1999. Institutions and Environmental Performance in Seventeen Western Democracies. British Journal of Political Science 29(1): 1-31.

______. 2001. “Is There Really a Link Between Neo-Corporatism and Environmental Performance? Updated Evidence and New Data for the 1980s and 1990s.” British Journal of Political Science 31(4): 686-692.

Shandra, John M. 2007. “Economic Dependency, Repression, and Deforestation: A Quantitative, Cross‐National Analysis.” Sociological Inquiry 77(4): 543-571.

Shandra, John M., Christopher Leckband, Laura A. McKinney, and Bruce London. 2009. “Ecologically Unequal Exchange, World Polity, and Biodiversity Loss: A Cross-National Analysis of Threatened Mammals.” International Journal of Comparative Sociology 50(3-4): 285-310.

Shandra, John M., Bruce London, Owen P. Whooley, and John B. Williamson. 2004. “International Nongovernmental Organizations and Carbon Dioxide Emissions in the Developing World: A Quantitative, Cross‐National Analysis.” Sociological Inquiry 74(4): 520-545.

Shandra, John M., Eric Shircliff, and Bruce London. 2010. “The International Monetary Fund, World Bank, and Structural Adjustment: A Cross-National Analysis of Forest Loss.” Social Science Research 40(1): 210-225.

______. 2011. “The International Monetary Fund, World Bank, and Structural Adjustment: A Cross-National Analysis of Forest Loss.” Social Science Research 40(1): 210-225.

Shandra, John M., and Eran Shor. 2008. “Debt, Structural Adjustment and Deforestation: A Cross-National Study.” Journal of World-Systems Research 14(1): 1-21.

Shandra, John M., Eran Shor, and Bruce London. 2008. “Debt, Structural Adjustment, and Organic Water Pollution: A Cross-National Analysis.” Organization & Environment 21(1): 38-55.

______. 2009. “World Polity, Unequal Ecological Exchange, and Organic Water Pollution: A Cross-National Analysis of Developing Nations.” Human Ecology Review 16(1): 53-63.

Shelton, Dinah. 1991. “Human Rights, Environmental Rights, and the Right to Environment.” Stanford Journal of International Law 28: 103.

Shorette, Kristen. 2012. “Outcomes of Global Environmentalism: Longitudinal and Cross-National Trends in Chemical Fertilizer and Pesticide Use.” Social Forces 91(1): 299-325.

Smith, Daniel J. 2018. “Corruption and ‘Culture’ in Anthropology and in Nigeria.” Current Anthropology 59(S18): S83-S91.

Sommer, Jamie M. 2017. “Grand and Petty Corruption: A Cross-National Analysis of Forest Loss in Low-And Middle-Income Nations.” Environmental Sociology 3(4): 414-426.

______. 2018. “State Spending and Governance: A Cross‐National Analysis of Forest Loss in Developing Nations.” Sociological Inquiry 88(4): 696-723.

Sommer, Jamie M., John M. Shandra, and Michael Restivo. 2017. “The World Bank, Contradictory Lending, and Forests: A Cross-National Analysis of Organized Hypocrisy.” International Sociology 32(6): 707-730.

Sommer, Jamie M., Michael Restivo, and John M. Shandra. 2020. “The United States, Bilateral Debt-for-Nature Swaps, and Forest Loss: A Cross-National Analysis.” The Journal of Development Studies 56, no. 4 (2020): 748-764.

UNEP 2017. “UNEP Study Confirms DR Congo's Potential as Environmental Powerhouse but Warns of Critical Threats.” UNEP: Nairobi, Kenya. https://www.unenvironment.org/news-and-stories/story/unep-study-confirms-dr-congos-potential-environmental-powerhouse-warns

Van Rossem, Ronan. 1996. “The World-systems Paradigm as General Theory of Development: A Cross-National Test.” American Sociological Review 61: 508-27.

Vanhanen, Tatu 2014. Global Inequality as a Consequence of Human Diversity. London, UK: Ulster Institute for Social Research.

Verburg, Peter H., John A. Dearing, James G. Dyke, Sander Van Der Leeuw, Sybil Seitzinger, Will Steffen, and James Syvitski. 2016. “Methods and Approaches to Modelling the Anthropocene.” Global Environmental Change 39: 328-340.

Wallerstein, Immanuel M.. 1974. “Dependence in an Interdependent World: The Limited Possibilities of Transformation Within the Capitalist World Economy.” African Studies Review 17(1): 1-26.

______. 2004. World-Systems Analysis: An Introduction. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

Walton, John, and Charles Ragin. 1990. “Global and National Sources of Political Protest: Third World Responses to the Debt Crisis.” American Sociological Review 55(6): 876-890.

Wang, Zhaohua, Bin Zhang, and Bo Wang. 2018. “The Moderating Role of Corruption Between Economic Growth and CO2 Emissions: Evidence from BRICS Economies.” Energy 148: 506-513.

Weaver, Catherine. 2008. Hypocrisy Trap: The World Bank and the Poverty of Reform. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Wooldridge, Jeffrey M. 2015. Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach: Fifth Edition. Mason, OH: South-Western.

World Bank. 2019. World Development Indicators. Washington, DC: World Bank.

Young, Oran R., Frans Berkhout, Gilberto C. Gallopin, Marco A. Janssen, Elinor Ostrom, and Sander Van der Leeuw. 2006. “The Globalization of Socio-Ecological Systems: An Agenda for Scientific Research.” Global Environmental Change 16(3): 304-316.

Published
2020-08-19
How to Cite
Sommer, J. M., & Hargrove, A. (2020). Power and Politics in the World-System: A Cross-National Analysis of Environmental Governance. Journal of World-Systems Research, 26(2), 263-287. https://doi.org/10.5195/jwsr.2020.998
Section
Special Issue: World-Systems Analysis in the Anthropocene