Capitalizing on Green Debt

A World-Ecology Analysis of Green Bonds in the Brazilian Forestry Sector

  • Tomaso Ferrando University of Antwerp
  • Gabriela De Oliveira Junqueira University of São Paulo
  • Marcela Vecchione-Gonçalves Federal University of Pará
  • Iagê Miola Federal University of São Paulo
  • Flávio Marques Prol The Brazilian Center of Analysis and Planning
  • Hector Herrera University of Antwerp
Keywords: green economy, green bonds, financialization of nature, forestry industry, world-ecology

Abstract

Green bonds represent an increasingly popular way to match “environmental sustainability,” growth, and the aspirations of global financial capital. In this article, we leverage a world-ecology approach to unpack and make sense of green bonds as public/private constructions that shape and subordinate the complex ecologies of territories to the needs of finance and reproduce the global patterns of uneven development and capitalist accumulation. Through the study of recent green bond issuances realized by private companies active in the forestry sector in Brazil, we discuss how green bonds as a “new” form of “green” debt put nature at work and transform the territories and natural elements in the global south into “temporal and spatial fixes” for the needs of global financial capital.

Author Biographies

Tomaso Ferrando, University of Antwerp

Tomaso Ferrando (he/him) is a Research Professor at the Faculty of Law (Law and Development Research Group) and the Institute of Development Policy at the University of Antwerp (Belgium). He holds a PhD in law from Sciences Po University (Paris) and has been visiting fellow at the Institute of Global Law and Policy (Harvard Law School), and visiting scholar at the University of Sao Paulo and the University of Cape Town. He researches the link between law and food systems, with particular attention to the implications in terms of food justice, along with the socio-legal-financial construction of Green Bonds as a new/old form of financing that combines the instrument of debt with the desire of building “sustainable” and “green” futures.

Gabriela De Oliveira Junqueira, University of São Paulo

Gabriela de Oliveira Junqueira is a PhD candidate at the Faculty of Law of the University of São Paulo.

Marcela Vecchione-Gonçalves, Federal University of Pará

Marcela Vecchione-Gonçalves (she/her) is an Associate Professor at the Centre of Advanced Amazonian Studies at the Federal University of the State of Pará (NAEA-UFPA), Brazil. She holds a postdoctoral research position at the Institute of Development Policy (IOB) at the University of Antwerp (2021-2023), Belgium, as a member of the project Environmental Policy Instruments across Commodity Chains (EPICC).

Iagê Miola, Federal University of São Paulo

Iagê Miola is a law professor at the Department of Law of the Federal University of São Paulo (UNIFESP) and a researcher at the Law and Democracy Nucleus of the Brazilian Center for Analysis and Planning (Cebrap). He holds PhD in Law and Society from the University of Milan, and has been a Visiting Scholar at the New York University (NYU), Department of Sociology.

Flávio Marques Prol, The Brazilian Center of Analysis and Planning

Flávio Marques Prol holds a PhD and Master of Laws from the University of Sao Paulo. He is currently a researcher at the Brazilian Center for Analysis and Planning (Cebrap). He was Fox Fellow at Yale University (2013-14) and Visiting Scholar at the Institute for Global Law and Policy at Harvard Law School (2016-17).

Hector Herrera, University of Antwerp

Hector Herrera is a PhD student at the Institute of Development Policy (IOB) at the University of Antwerp (Belgium) where he researches Green City Bonds from the perspective of climate and water justice.

References

Aglietta, Michel, Jean-Charles Hourcade, Carlo Jaeger and Baptiste P. Fabert. 2015. “Financing transition in an adverse context: climate finance beyond carbon finance”. International environmental agreements: politics, law and economics 15(4):403-20.

Ahrens, Sérgio and Yeda M. M. Oliveira. 2017. “Plantações florestais comerciais, a certificação e os diálogos setoriais”. In de Oliveira, Yeda M. M. And Edilson B. De Oliveira, eds. Plantações Florestais: geração de benefícios com baixo impacto ambiental, Brasília: Embrapa, pp. 73-8.

Alves da Silva and Thiago Lucas. 2018. “A apropriação capitalista da silvicultura no Brasil e sua lógica de produção do espaço”. Terra Livre 33(1):159-99.

Antal, Miklós and Jeroen Van Den Bergh. 2016. “Green growth and climate change: conceptual and empirical considerations”. Climate Policy 16(2):165-77.

Baker, Sophie. 2021. “Green Bonds show evidence of ‘greenium’ in second half of 2020”. Pension & Investments (March 11). Retrieved April 20, 2021 (https://www.pionline.com/esg/green-bonds-show-evidence-greenium-second-half-2020).

Barbosa, Rodney Alves, Marcelo L. R. Oliveira, Katia F. Vilela and Mariane B. Roque. 2019. “Expansão da monocultura de eucalipto das indústrias de papel e celulose: uma arena de conflitos ambientais”. Polêm!ca 19(1):69-90.

Bigger, Patrick and Nate Millington. 2019. “Getting soaked? Climate crisis, adaptation finance, and racialized austerity”. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space 3(3), 601-623.

Borges, Ana. 2019. “Finanças sustentáveis: a iniciativa privada assume a responsabilidade”. Revista RI 234:10-18.

Bracking, Sarah. 2019. “Financialisation, climate finance, and the calculative challenges of managing environmental change”. Antipode 51(3):709-29.

Celulose Irani. 2020. “Relatório de sustentabilidade 2019”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (http://www.irani.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Irani_Relatório-Sustentabilidade-2019-1.pdf).

Cerrato, Davide and Ferrando, Tomaso. 2020. "The Financialization of Civil Society Activism: Sustainable Finance, Non-Financial Disclosure and the Shrinking Space for Engagement" Accounting, Economics, and Law: A Convivium 10(2): 1-27.

Clark, Giovani and Leonardo Alves Corrêa. 2012. “Direito económico, meio ambiente e biocombustíveis no Brasil: leitura crítica à luz do marxismo nacional de Caio Prado Junior”. Lusíada. Economia & Empresa 15:159-80.

Climate Bonds Initiative. 2020a. “Green Bonds global state of the market 2019”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://www.climatebonds.net/system/tdf/reports/cbi_sotm_2019_vol1_04d.pdf?file=1&type=node&id=47577).

_____. 2020b. “Explaining green bonds”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://www.climatebonds.net/market/explaining-green-bonds).

_____. 2021. “Sustainable debt global state of the market 2020”. Retrieved July 31, 2021 (https://www.climatebonds.net/files/reports/cbi_sd_sotm_2020_04d.pdf).

Dalbó, Juliana, Filgueiras, Lívia Alves Filgueiras and Mendes, Anderson Nogueira Mendes. 2020. “Effects of pesticides on rural workers: haematological parameters and symptomalogical reports.” at Ciência & Saúde Coletiva [online]. 2019, v. 24, n. 7 [Accessed 25 July 2021] , pp. 2569-2582. Available from: <https://doi.org/10.1590/1413-81232018247.19282017>. Epub 22 July 2019. ISSN 1678-4561. https://doi.org/10.1590/1413-81232018247.19282017.

Escobar, Arturo. 1994. Encountering development – the making and unmaking of the Third World. Princeton University Press.

European Commission. 2012. “Innovation for Sustainable Growth. A Bioeconomy for Europe”. Retrieved August 10, 2021.

(https://ec.europa.eu/research/bioeconomy/pdf/bioeconomycommunicationstrategy_b5_brochure_web.pdf)

European Investment Bank (EIB). 2020. “Climate awareness bonds”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://www.eib.org/en/investor_relations/cab/index.htm).

European Union. 2020. “European Union Technical Expert Group on sustainable finance”. Technical report: taxonomy – final report of the technical expert group on sustainable finance. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/business_economy_euro/banking_and_finance/documents/200309-sustainable-finance-teg-final-report-taxonomy_en.pdf).

Ferrando, Tomaso. 2017. “Land Rights at the Time of Global Production: Leveraging Multi-Spatiality and ‘Legal Chokeholds’”. Business and Human Rights Journal, 2(2): 275-295.

Flammer, Caroline. 2018. “Corporate Green Bonds”. Global Development Policy Center Working Paper 023. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://www.bu.edu/gdp/files/2018/11/GEGI-GDP.WP_.Corporate-Green-Bonds.pdf).

_____. 2020. “Green bonds: effectiveness and implications for public policy”. Environmental and Energy Policy and the Economy 1(1):95-128.

Gibson-Graham, J. K. 2008. “Diverse economies: performative practices for other worlds”. Progress in human geography, 32(5):613-32.

Harvey, David. 1982. The Limits to Capital, Oxford: Blackwell and Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

_____. 2001a. Spaces of Capital: Towards a Critical Geography. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press; New York: Routledge.

_____. 2001b. “Globalization and the ‘spatial fix’”. Geographische Revue, 2:23-30.

_____. 2003. The New Imperialism, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Hazeu, Marcel T., Marcela Vecchione-Gonçalves, and Solange M. G. Costa. 2020. “Mobilidade do capital e estratégias de acumulação capitalista na Amazônia e no Cerrado Brasileiros”. Revista de Politica Públicas da UFMA 20:433-455.

Hilbrandt, Hanna and Monika Grubbauer. 2020. ‘Standards and SSOs in the contested widening and deepening of financial markets: the arrival of green municipal bonds in Mexico City’, Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 52 1415-1433.

Indústria Brasileira de Árvores. 2019. “Relatório Anual 2019”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://iba.org/datafiles/publicacoes/relatorios/relatorioiba2019-final.pdf).

International Financial Corporation. 2020. “Emerging Market Green Bonds Report 2019”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://www.ifc.org/wps/wcm/connect/topics_ext_content/ifc_external_corporate_site/climate+business/resources/em-gb-report-2019).

International Financial Corporation, Climate Bonds Initiative. 2018. “Creating Green Bond Markets – Insights, innovations, and tools from emerging markets”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://www.ifc.org/wps/wcm/connect/topics_ext_content/ifc_external_corporate_site/sustainability-at-ifc/company-resources/sustainable-finance/SBN_GreenBond).

Jessop, Bob. 2004. “On the Limits of Limits to Capital”. Antipode, 36(3):480-496

_____. 2012. “Economic and ecological crises, green new deals and no-growth economies”. Developments, 55(1):17-24.

Jones, Ryan, Tom Baker, Katherine Huet, Laurence Murphy and Nick Lewis. 2020. “Treating ecological deficit with debt: the practical and political concerns with green bonds”. Geoforum 114:49-58.

Klabin. 2020a. “Relatório de Sustentabilidade”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://rs.klabin.com.br).

_____. 2020b. “Apresentação Institutional 2T20”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://s3.amazonaws.com/mz-filemanager/1c41fa99-efe7-4e72-81dd-5b571f5aa376/e901af62-326f-4da0-9635-6200f039f24b_klabin%20ap.%20institucional%202t20_port_compressed%20%281%29.pdf).

Kröger, Markus. 2008. “Finland, Brazil and State-Business Relations: The Case of Brazilian Pulp Investments”. in BRASA IX, Tulane University, New Orleans, March 27-29, 2008 Brazil Today, Trans-Atlantically, Brazilian Studies Association conference: Brazilian Studies Association Conference 2008, New Orleans.

_____. 2012. “The Expansion of Industrial Tree Plantations and Dispossession in Brazil”. Development and Change 43(4):947-73.

_____. 2013. “Globalization as the “Pulping” of Landscapes: Forestry Capitalism’s North-South Territorial Accumulation”. Globalizations 10(6):837-53.

_____. 2014. “The political economy of global tree plantation expansion: a review”. The Journal of Peasant Studies 41(2):235-61.

_____. 2015. “O papel do Estado brasileiro na criação de fronteira capitalista e novas naturezas no passado e futuro”. In Santana, Carlos H. And Wagner Iglecias eds. Estado, burocracia e controle democrático. São Paulo: Alameda, pp. 171-96.

_____. 2016. “The Political Economy of ‘Flex Trees’: A Preliminary Analysis”. The Journal of Peasant Studies 43(4):886-909.

KPMG. 2015. “Gearing Up for Green Bonds”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://assets.kpmg/content/dam/kpmg/pdf/2015/03/gearing-up-for-green-bonds-v1.pdf).

Kudavicz, Mieceslau and Rosemeire A. de Almeida. 2014. “Em tempos de “privatização” da reforma agrária, a necessária práxis do bem comum”. Boletim DATALUTA – Artigo do mês: fevereiro de 2014.

Kuhlmann, Wolfgang, Merel Van der Mark and Sergio Baffoni. 2019. “Industrial Tree Plantations and Green Bonds”. Environmental Paper Network. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://environmentalpaper.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/EPN-2019-Industrial-tree-plantations-and-green-bonds.pdf).

Lapavitsas, Costas. 2013. Profiting without producing. London/New York: Verso.

MAPA. 2018. “Plano Nacional de Desenvolvimento de Florestas Plantadas”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://www.gov.br/agricultura/pt-br/assuntos/politica-agricola/outras-publicacoes/plano-nacional-de-desenvolvimento-de-florestas-plantadas.pdf/view ).

Marks, Susan. (2011). “Human rights and root causes”. The Modern Law Review 74(1):57-78.

Marques, Marta I. M. 2016. “A territorialização da empresa Suzano no campo em São Paulo e no Maranhão”. Revista GeoNordeste 27(2):213-27.

Miola, Iagê, Gabriela, de Oliveira Junqueira, Flávio, Prol, et al. 2021. “Bonos verdes en la ecología-mundo: capital, naturaleza y poder en la expansión financiarizada de la industria forestal en Brasil”. Relaciones Internacionales 46: 161-180.

Moore, Jason W. 2003. “Capitalism as world-ecology: Braudel and Marx on environmental history”. Organization & Environment 16(4):431-458.

_____. 2011. “Wall Street is a way of organizing nature: an interview with Jason Moore”. Upping the Anti: A Journal of Theory and Action 12:39-54.

_____. 2014a. “The end of cheap nature. Or how I learned to stop worrying about “The” environment and love the crisis of capitalism”. In Suter, C. and Christopher Chase-Dunn eds. Structures of the World Political Economy and the Future of Global Conflict and Cooperation, Berlin: LIT, pp. 285-314.

_____. 2014b. “Toward a singular metabolism: epistemic rifts and environment- making in the capitalist world-ecology”. New Geographies 06:10-19.

_____. 2015a. Capitalism in the web of life. London: Verso.

_____. 2015b. “Cheap food and bad climate: From surplus value to negative value in the capitalist world-ecology”. Critical Historical Studies 2(1):1-43.

Moore, Jason and Raj Patel. 2018. The History of the World in Seven Cheap Things. London: Verso.

OECD. 2017. “Mobilizing bond markets for a low-carbon transition”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://www.oecd.org/env/mobilising-bond-markets-for-a-low-carbon-transition-9789264272323-en.htm).

Oliveira, Allison B., Jesus M. Pereira and Amanda A. Nascimento. 2018. “Cadeia produtiva de papel e celulose e transformações recentes no sudoeste maranhense”. Revista de Geografia e Interdisciplinaridade 4(12):135-54.

O’Neill, Brian F. 2020. “The world ecology of desalination – from Cold War positioning to financialization in the Capitalocene”. Journal of World-Systems Research 36(2):318-49.

Pantoja, Vanda M. L. and Jesus M. Pereira. 2016. “Grandes projetos e populações tradicionais na Amazônia: a Suzano Papel e Celulose no Maranhão”. Revista Política & Trabalho 45:327-40.

Paranque, Bernard and Christophe Revelli. 2019. “Ethico-economic analysis of impact finance: the case of Green Bonds”. Research in International Business and Finance 47:57-66.

Parenti, Christian. 2016. “Environment-making in the Capitalocene – Political Ecology of the State”. In Moore, Jason W. ed., Anthropocene or Capitalocene? Nature, history, and the crisis of capitalism, PM Press, pp. 166-84.

Park, Stephan K. 2018. “Investors as regulators: green bonds and the governance challenges of the sustainable finance revolution”. Stanford Journal of International Law 54:1-47.

Padro Jr., C. 2011. Formaçao do Brasil Contemporâneo. Sao Paulo: Companhia das Letras.

Perez, Oren. 2008. “The new universe of green finance: from self-regulation to multi-polar governance”. In Dilling, Olaf, Martin Herberg, and Gerd Winter eds. Responsible Business: Self-Governance and Law in Transnational Economic Transactions, London: Hart Publishing, pp. 151-80.

_____. 2016. “The green economy paradox: a critical inquiry into sustainability indexes”. Minnesota Journal of Law, Science and Technology 17(1):153-220.

Perpetua, Guilherme M., Markus Kröger, and Antonio Thomaz Jr. 2017. “Estratégias de territorialização das corporações agroextrativistas na América Latina: o caso da indústria de celulose no Brasil”. Revista NERA 20(40):61-87.

Pistor, Katharina. 2013. A Legal Theory of Finance, Journal of Comparative Economics, Vol. 41: 315.

_____. 2019. The code of capital. Princeton University Press.

Polanyi, Karl. 1944. The great transformation. Farrar and Rinehart.

Pompeia, Caio. 2021. A formação política do agronegócio. Editora Elefante.

Prol, Flávio. Junqueira, Gabriela. Marques, Marta. Ferrando, Tomaso. 2020. “Green finance at the service of the neoliberal far-right: the wrecking of environmental regulation and the rise of green bonds in Brazil”. At Revista de Ecología Política, n 59.

Reyes, Oscar. 2020. “Change finance, not the climate”. Amsterdam and Washington: Transnational Institute (TNI) and the Institute for Policy Studies (IPS). Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://www.tni.org/files/publication-downloads/change_finance_not_the_climate_online_def.pdf).

Sachs, Jeffrey, Wing T. Woo, Naoyuki Yoshino, and Farhad Taghizadeh-Hesary. 2019. “Importance of green finance for achieving sustainable development goals and energy security”. In Sachs, J., Wing T. Woo, Naoyuki Yoshino, and Farhad Taghizadeh-Hesary eds. Handbook of Green Finance, Singapore: Springer pp. 3-12.

Sankara, Thomas. 1987. A United Front Against Debt, Speech at the Organisation of African Unity in July 1987, in Committee for the Abolition of Illegitimate Debt, October 27, 2011, available at www.cadtm.org/spip.php?page=imprimer&id_article=13533.

Shishlov, Igor, Morgane Nicol, and Ian Cochram. 2018. “Environmental integrity of green bonds: stakes, status and next steps”. Green Bonds Research Program Work Package 2. Climate Works Foundation. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://www.i4ce.org/download/environmental-integrity-of-green-bonds/).

Silva, Mariele and Rosemeire Almeida. 2014. “Esgotamento da política pública de reforma agrária?” Revista Eletrônica da Associação dos Geógrafos Brasileiros – Seção Três Lagoas 11(20):60-84.

Silva Neta, Maria Querobina. 2018. Sou uma mulher praticamente livre, edited by Alfredo W. B. de Almeida. Rio de Janeiro: Casa 8.

Sitawi. 2019. “Parecer Independente – Debênture Verde da Celulose Irani”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://spositawi.s3-sa-east-1.amazonaws.com/20190719+Celulose+Irani.pdf).

_____. 2020. “Operações brasileiras sustentáveis de crédito”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/u/1/d/e/2PACX-1vRDp7Z82Qovj9VuupGGQGSiBi66hQPdRL5ucb6kZ80HyjtQtVjjtf7Qekh99_DVs2FRG-8ADHE05ASP/pubhtml).

Suzano. 2019. Suzano is born from the combination of Suzano Pulp and Paper and Fibria. Retrieved August 2, 2021 (https://www.suzano.com.br/en/suzano-is-born-from-the-combination-of-suzano-pulp-paper-and-fibria/).

_____. 2020. “Relatório de Sustentabilidade 2019”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://storage.googleapis.com/stateless-site-suzano-com-br/2020/05/c133f4c6-rasuzano2019.pdf).

Sustainalytics. 2016a. “Suzano Papel e Celulose S.A. Green Bond – Framework Overview and Second Opinion.” Retrieved July 5, 2020 (https://www.icmagroup.org/Emails/icma-vcards/Suzano_External%20Review%20Report.pdf).

_____. 2016b. “Fibria Green Bond - Framework Overview and Second Opinion”. Retrieved July 5, 2020 (https://www.sustainalytics.com/sites/default/files/green_bond_framework_and_opinion_fibria.pdf).

_____. 2017. “Klabin Green Bond - Framework Overview and Second Opinion”. Retrieved July 5, 2020 (https://www.sustainalytics.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Klabin-Green-Bond-Framework-and-Opinion-08302017_FINAL.pdf).

The Forest Company. “Operations”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (http://www.theforestcompany.se/our-operations).

Toledo, Marcelo H. S. (2012). “O impacto da plantação extensiva de eucalipto nas culturas tradicionais”. Cadernos IHUideias, 10(167).

Tolliver, Clarence, Alexander R. Keeley and Shunsuke Managi. 2019. “Green bonds for the Paris Agreement and Sustainable Development Goals”. Environmental Research Letters 14.

United Nations Environment Programme. 2021. State of finance for Nature 2021. Nairobi

Van Apeldoorn, Bastian, Naná de Graaff and Henk Overbeek. 2012. “The Reconfiguration of the Global State–Capital Nexus”, Globalizations, 9(4):471:486

Vecchione-Gonçalves, Marcela. 2018. “Acumulação por legislação: Código Florestal e Cadastro Ambiental Rural como zoneamento da expansão do agronegócio e da apropriação de terras nos Cerrados”. Revista Cerrados – CPT 44-55.

Voivodic, Mauricio A. and Luiz Carlos Beduschi Filho. 2011. “Os desafios de legitimidade em sistemas multissetoriais de governança: uma análise do Forest Stewardship Council”. Ambiente & Sociedade 14(1):115-32.

Wacquant, Loïc. 1985. “Heuristic models in Marxian theory”. Social Forces 64(1):17-45.

Weber, Olaf and Vasundhara Saravade. 2019. “Green bonds – current development and their future”. Center for International Governance Information Paper n. 2010. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://www.cigionline.org/publications/green-bonds-current-development-and-their-future).

World Bank. 2017. “Green Bonds”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (http://pubdocs.worldbank.org/en/554231525378003380/publicationpensionfundservicegreenbonds201712-rev.pdf).

WRM. 2013. “FSC consultation and complaints procedures: the case of Veracel Celulose in Brazil”. Retrieved October 4, 2020 (https://wrm.org.uy/books-and-briefings/new-briefing-on-fsc-certification-of-plantations/).

Zhang, Dayong, Zhiwei Zhang, and Shunsuke Managi. 2019. “A bibliometric analysis on green finance: current status, development and future directions”. Finance Research Letters 29:425-30.

Zografos, Christos, and Paul Robbins. 2020. “Green Sacrifice Zones, or Why a Green New Deal Cannot Ignore the Cost Shifts of Just Transitions”. One Earth, 3(5):543-546.

Published
2021-08-14
How to Cite
Ferrando, T., De Oliveira Junqueira, G., Vecchione-Gonçalves, M., Miola, I., Marques Prol, F., & Herrera, H. (2021). Capitalizing on Green Debt: A World-Ecology Analysis of Green Bonds in the Brazilian Forestry Sector . Journal of World-Systems Research, 27(2), 410-438. https://doi.org/10.5195/jwsr.2021.1062
Section
Research Articles