The World-System and the Earth System

Struggles with the Society/Nature Binary in World-System Analysis and Ecological Marxism

  • Alf Hornborg University of Lund, Sweden
Keywords: ecologically unequal exchange, society/nature distinction, theories of value, ecological Marxism, technological progress

Abstract

Efforts to conceptualize the role of asymmetric resource transfers in the capitalist world-system have been constrained by the emphasis on surplus value and the labor theory of value in Marxist thought. A coherent theory of ecologically unequal exchange must focus on asymmetric flows of biophysical resources such as embodied labor, land, energy, and materials. To conceptualize these flows in terms of  “underpaid costs” or “surplus value” is to suggest that the metabolism of the world-system can be accounted for using a monetary metric. This paper rejects both labor and energy theories of value in favor of the observation that market pricing tends to lead to asymmetric resource flows. The Marxist labor theory of value is an economic argument, rather than a physical one. In acknowledging this we may transcend the recent debate within ecological Marxism about whether “nature” and “society” are valid categories. Nature and society are ontologically entwined, as in the undertheorized phenomenon of modern technology, but should be kept analytically distinct. Since the Industrial Revolution, technological progress has been contingent on the societal ratios by which biophysical resources are exchanged on the world market. The failure among Marxist and world-system theorists to properly account for this central aspect of capitalist accumulation can be traced to the pervasive assumption that market commodities have objective values that may exceed their price. Instead of arguing with mainstream economists about whether market assessments of value are justified, it is more analytically robust to observe that market valuation is destroying the biosphere.

References

Altvater, Elmar. 2007. “The Social and Natural Environment of Fossil Capitalism.” Socialist Register 43: 37-59.

Amin, Samir. 1976. Unequal Development. New York: Monthly Review Press.

Borgström, Georg. 1965. The Hungry Planet. New York: Collier.

Brennan, Teresa. 1997. “Economy for the Earth: The Labour Theory of Value Without the Subject/Object Distinction.” Ecological Economics 20: 175-185.

Bunker, Stephen G. 1985. Underdeveloping the Amazon: Extraction, Unequal Exchange, and the Failure of the Modern State. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

______. 2007. “Natural Values and the Physical Inevitability of Uneven Development under Capitalism.” Pp. 239-258 in Rethinking Environmental History: World-System History and Global Environmental Change, edited by Alf Hornborg, John R. McNeill, and Joan Martinez-Alier. Lanham: AltaMira.

Bunker, Stephen G. and Paul S. Ciccantell. 1999. “Economic Ascent and the Global Environment: World-Systems Theory and the New Historical Materialism.” Pp. 107-122 in Ecology and the World-System, edited by Walter L. Goldfrank, David Goodman, and Andrew Szasz. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.

______. 2005. Globalization and the Race for Resources. Baltimore, Md.: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

Burkett, Paul. 2003. “The Value Problem in Ecological Economics.” Organization & Environment 16(2): 137-167.

______. [1999] 2014. Marx and Nature: A Red and Green Perspective. Chicago: Haymarket.

Burkett, Paul and John B. Foster. 2006. “Metabolism, Energy, and Entropy in Marx’s Critique of Political Economy: Beyond the Podolinsky Myth.” Theory and Society 35:109-156.

Clark, Brett and John B. Foster. 2012. “Guano: The Global Metabolic Rift and the Fertilizer Trade.” Pp. 68-82 in Ecology and Power: Struggles over Land and Material Resources in the Past, Present and Future, edited by Alf Hornborg, Brett Clark, and Kenneth Hermele. London: Routledge.

Clark, Brett and Richard York. 2005. “Carbon Metabolism: Global Capitalism, Climate Change, and the Biospheric Rift.” Theory and Society 34: 391-428.

Deléage, Jean-Paul. 1989. “Eco-Marxist Critique of Political Economy.” Capitalism Nature Socialism 1 (3): 15-31.

Dorninger, Christian, and Alf Hornborg. 2015. “Can EEMRIO Analyses Establish the Occurrence of Ecologically Unequal Exchange?” Ecological Economics 119: 414–18.

Emmanuel, Arghiri. 1972. Unequal Exchange: A Study of the Imperialism of Trade. New York: Monthly Review Press.

Foster, John B. 2000. Marx’s Ecology: Materialism and Nature. New York: Monthly Review Press.

______. 2008. “Peak Oil and Energy Imperialism.” Monthly Review 60(3): 12-33.

______. 2014. “Foreword.” Pp. vi-xiii in Marx and Nature: A Red and Green Perspective, edited by Paul Burkett. Chicago, IL: Haymarket.

______. 2018. “Marx, Value, and Nature.” Monthly Review, July 1, 2018.

Foster, John B. and Paul Burkett. 2004. “Ecological Economics and Classical Marxism: The ‘Podolinsky Business’ Reconsidered.” Organization & Environment 17(1): 32-60.

______. 2008. “Classical Marxism and the Second Law of Thermodynamics: Marx/Engels, the Heat Death of the Universe Hypothesis, and the Origins of Ecological Economics.” Organization & Environment 21(1): 3-37.

______. 2016. Marx and the Earth: An Anti-critique. Leiden: Brill.

______. 2018. “Value Isn’t Everything.” Monthly Review 70(6), November 1, 2018.

Foster, John B. and Brett Clark. 2004. “Ecological Imperialism: The Curse of Capitalism.” Socialist Register 2004: 186-201.

Foster, John B. and Hanna Holleman. 2014. “The Theory of Unequal Ecological Exchange: A Marx-Odum Dialectic.” The Journal of Peasant Studies 41(2): 199-233.

Foster, John B., Brett Clark and Richard York. 2010. The Ecological Rift: Capitalism’s War on the Earth. New York: Monthly Review Press.

Foster, John B., Hannah Holleman and Brett Clark. 2019. “Imperialism in the Anthropocene.” Monthly Review, July-August 2019.

Gellert, Paul K. 2019. “Bunker’s Ecologically Unequal Exchange, Foster’s Metabolic Rift, and Moore’s World-Ecology: Distinctions With or Without a Difference?” Pp. 107-140 in Ecologically Unequal Exchange: Environmental Injustice in Comparative and Historical Perspective, edited by R. Scott Frey, Paul K. Gellert and Harry F. Dahms. Houndmills, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.

Georgescu-Roegen, Nicholas. 1971. The Entropy Law and the Economic Process. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Hornborg, Alf. 1998a. “Ecosystems and World Systems: Accumulation as an Ecological Process.” Journal of World-Systems Research 4(2): 169-177.

______. 1998b. “Towards an Ecological Theory of Unequal Exchange: Articulating World System Theory and Ecological Economics.” Ecological Economics 25(1): 127-136.

______. 2001. The Power of the Machine: Global Inequalities of Economy, Technology, and Environment. Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira.

______. 2015. “Why Economics Needs to be Distinguished from Physics, and Why Economists Need to Talk to Physicists: A Response to Foster and Holleman.” Journal of Peasant Studies 42(1): 187-192.

______. 2017. “Artifacts have Consequences, not Agency: Toward a Critical Theory of Global Environmental History.” European Journal of Social Theory 20(1): 95-110.

______. 2019a. Nature, Society, and Justice in the Anthropocene: Unraveling the Money-Energy-Technology Complex. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

______. 2019b. “The Money-Energy-Technology Complex and Ecological Marxism: Rethinking the Concept of “Use-value” to Extend our Understanding of Unequal Exchange, Part I.” Capitalism Nature Socialism 30(3): 27-39.

Hornborg, Alf and Carole L. Crumley, eds. 2007. The World System and the Earth System: Global Socioenvironmental Change and Sustainability Since the Neolithic. Walnut Creek: Left Coast Press.

Hornborg, Alf, John R. McNeill and Joan Martinez-Alier, eds. 2007. Rethinking Environmental History: World-System History and Global Environmental Change. Lanham: AltaMira.

Huber, Matthew T. 2008. “Energizing Historical Materialism: Fossil Fuels, Space and the Capitalist Mode of Production.” Geoforum 40: 105-115.

Latour, Bruno. 1993. We Have Never Been Modern. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

______. 2017. Facing Gaia: Eight Lectures on the New Climatic Regime. Cambridge: Polity.

Lonergan, Stephen C. 1988. “Theory and Measurement of Unequal Exchange: A Comparison Between a Marxist Approach and an Energy Theory of Value.” Ecological Modeling 41:127-145.

Malm, Andreas. 2016. Fossil Capital: The Rise of Steam Power and the Roots of Global Warming. London: Verso.

______. 2018. The Progress of this Storm: Nature and Society in a Warming World. London: Verso.

Malm, Andreas and Alf Hornborg. 2014. “The Geology of Mankind? A Critique of the Anthropocene Narrative.” The Anthropocene Review 1: 62-69.

Martinez-Alier, Joan, and José M. Naredo. 1982. “A Marxist Precursor of Energy Economics: Podolinsky.” The Journal of Peasant Studies 9 (2): 207-224.

Marx, Karl. [1867] 1967. Capital, vol.1. New York: International Publishers.

______. [1867] 1976. Capital, vol.1. Harmondsworth, UK: Penguin Books.

Moore, Jason W. 2000a. “Marx and the Historical Ecology of Capital Accumulation on a World Scale: A Comment on Alf Hornborg’s ‘Ecosystems and World Systems: Accumulation as an Ecological Process.’” Journal of World-Systems Research VI(1): 133-138.

______. 2000b. “Environmental Crises and the Metabolic Rift in World-Historical Perspective.” Organization & Environment 13(2): 123-157.

______. 2001. “Book Review Essay: (Re)discovering Marx’s Materialism.” Organization & Environment 14(2): 240-245.

______. 2007. “Silver, Ecology, and the Origins of the Modern World, 1450-1640.” Pp. 123 -142 in Rethinking Environmental History: World-System History and Global Environmental Change, edited by Alf Hornborg, John R. McNeill, and Joan Martinez-Alier. Lanham, MD: AltaMira.

______. 2011. “Transcending the Metabolic Rift: A Theory of Crisis in the Capitalist World-Ecology.” Journal of Peasant Studies 38(1): 1-46.

______. 2015. Capitalism in the Web of Life: Ecology and the Accumulation of Capital. London: Verso.

______. 2016. “The Rise of Cheap Nature.” Pp. 78-115 in Anthropocene or Capitalocene? Nature, History, and the Crisis of Capitalism, edited by Jason W. Moore. Oakland, CA: PM Press.

O’Connor, James. 1998. Natural Causes: Essays in Ecological Marxism. New York: Guilford.

Odum, Howard T. 1988. “Self-organization, Transformity, and Information.” Science 242: 1132-1139.

Odum, Howard T. and Jan E. Arding. 1991. Emergy Analysis of Shrimp Mariculture in Ecuador. Working Paper, Coastal Resources Center, University of Rhode Island, Narragansett.

Podolinsky, Sergei. [1883] 2008. Human labor and the unity of force. Historical Materialism 16: 163-183.

Polanyi, Karl. [1944] 1957. The Great Transformation: The Political and Economic Origins of Our Time. Boston, MA: Beacon.

Roberts, J. Timmons and Peter E. Grimes. 1999. “Extending the World-System to the Whole System: Toward a Political Economy of the Biosphere.” Pp. 59-83 in Ecology and the World-System, edited by Walter L. Goldfrank, David Goodman, and Andrew Szasz. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.

Salleh, Ariel. 1997. Ecofeminism as Politics. London: Zed Books.

Wackernagel, Mathis and William E. Rees. 1996. Our Ecological Footprint: Reducing Human Impact on the Earth. Gabriola Island, BC: New Society Publishers.

Wallerstein, Immanuel. 1999. “Ecology and Capitalist Costs of Production: No Exit.” Pp. 3-11 in Ecology and the World-System, edited by Walter L. Goldfrank, David Goodman, and Andrew Szasz. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.

Published
2020-08-19
How to Cite
Hornborg, A. (2020). The World-System and the Earth System: Struggles with the Society/Nature Binary in World-System Analysis and Ecological Marxism. Journal of World-Systems Research, 26(2), 184-202. https://doi.org/10.5195/jwsr.2020.989
Section
Special Issue: World-Systems Analysis in the Anthropocene